ENGLAND’S Champions Trophy plans may be in for a lastminute overhaul after their unexpected back-to-back NatWest Series defeats against New Zealand.
Injured pace bowlers Stuart Broad and Steven Finn have yet to be officially ruled out of tomorrow’s final match of three against the Kiwis at Trent Bridge.
After Sunday’s 86-run humbling by the Kiwis at the Ageas Bowl, however, England captain Alastair Cook already was unsure whether the two key seamers may yet also have to sit out Saturday’s Champions Trophy opener against Australia at Edgbaston.
With Tim Bresnan on alert to dash off at any time to be with his wife in Halifax for the birth of their first child, and Jade Dernbach and Chris Woakes unable to contain New Zealand on Sunday, frowns are everywhere as England’s management team tries to come up with a serviceable attack.
Only James Anderson and Graeme Swann remain fit and reliable components as England contemplate first of all how to avoid a 3-0 whitewash against New Zealand – their only ODI series defeat of any kind on home soil since 2009.
Cook baulked at the suggestion Broad and Finn’s continued absence might completely undermine England’s ODI effectiveness. ‘‘I think that would be doing a disservice to the other 13 guys in the squad,’’ he said, acknowledging nonetheless he and coach Ashley Giles may now need to ponder a re-deployment of their bowling resources.
‘‘Clearly, you take two premier bowlers out of anyone’s side, and it’s going to hurt the side.
‘‘You might have to change the way you play. We might have just learnt that.’’ Cook, whose team fell well short in Southampton of what would have been the second- highest successful ODI run chase in history, added: ‘‘You do tend to look, don’t you, after a couple of defeats like this at the balance and make-up of your side.
‘‘Clearly, when you get that right – like we did against Australia (in a 4-0 series victory) last year – we’re a very hard side to beat.
‘‘We’ve certainly got options to go both ways.
‘‘If we’d won these games, using the five (frontline) bowlers, then we’d be less likely to change.
‘‘But at this point, I’m sure we’ll be looking at different combinations – because the ones we’ve just used haven’t worked in these two games.’’ The leeway available to England, from their squad of 15 if Broad and Finn do not recover quickly, includes a return – in the unaccustomed role of bowling all-rounder – of one-time specialist batsman Ravi Bopara, who was released to play for Essex yesterday.
Slightly more conventionally, but less likely in mid-summer English conditions, they could consider the use of a second specialist off-spinner - James Tredwell as well as Swann.
Alternatively, part-time bowlers Joe Root and Jonathan Trott could be asked to fiddle through a full ten overs or more between them.
Whatever the result of deliberations, captain and coach may well be cooking up a change of personnel in Nottingham – having stuck with a losing team after Lord’s, and come up short again.
Comments: Our rules
We want our comments to be a lively and valuable part of our community - a place where readers can debate and engage with the most important local issues. The ability to comment on our stories is a privilege, not a right, however, and that privilege may be withdrawn if it is abused or misused.
Please report any comments that break our rules.
Read the rules here