Flats proposal for Medieval site sparks conservation anger

An application submitted to Hambleton District Council for the development in Chapel Street, Thirsk, has sparked controversy in the town.

North Yorkshire County Council archaeologists have confirmed the site is situated on the line of early Medieval town defences and are asking for a full appraisal of the area to be carried out before any building starts.

Thirsk and Sowerby Civic Society has also voiced concerns over the Aspect Homes plans, saying three storeys is too high and would dominate the skyline at the end of Chapel Street.

A spokesman said: "The civic society is also rather concerned at the building of residential dwellings in a mainly industrial and commercial area.

"This is also an area with considerable access problems at the best of times.

"We would like to point out that this development will increase pressure on Chapel Street."

Chapel Street is described by town councillors as "a very difficult area of Thirsk", and they fear the building could be too large and overpowering.

However, the proposals have won the backing of council officers, who are recommending to planning committee members that the scheme should be given approval.

Hambleton's development control officer, Tony Harper, said: "The proposal should not have an adverse effect on the conservation area.

"The proposed development can provide for an acceptable residential environment. Although the site is limited, it is considered that the proposed building can be satisfactorily accommodated."

He said: "Although a three-storey building is proposed, this height relates well to existing buildings in the area, including the workshop over Chapel Street, and the residential development to the east of the site.

"The design of the proposal is also considered acceptable in terms of proportions, scale and detailing."

The application will be considered at a meeting of the council's planning committee on Thursday, January 4, at the Civic Centre, Northallerton