AN annual review of the affairs of a North Yorkshire market town, which has pulled few punches in its criticism of the performance of the local authorities in the past, describes a much more positive year in 2003.

The Richmond Civic Society publishes its booklet each December, which includes articles on both the history and newly-uncovered aspects of the town's heritage.

This year's publication tells the story of Bargate, some of the local boundary marks and milestones and the town's Georgian court.

The chairman's report assesses recent changes in the fabric and appearance of the town - and has often included some biting criticism of issues which members feel have been to the detriment of the community.

This year, Bev Joicey suggests the closure of the Black Lion as a result of a legal dispute between the tenant and landlord has dragged on for too long, although the Pubmaster chain has always emphasised it is keen to resolve the matter as quickly as possible.

He has also indicated the society has concerns about some aspects of a North Yorkshire County Council traffic survey - particularly the suggestion that buses are moved from the Market Place to new bays on Queen's Road, next to the Friary Gardens.

However, overall, Mr Joicey believes 2003 has been a positive year for Richmond.

"There are certainly grounds for optimism," he said.

"The Swale Valley Initiative has given us a long-term plan to build on for the area while the formation of the group pioneering the idea of converting the old station into a community resource could be a model adopted elsewhere.

He continued: "We would like to see a speedy solution to problems with the Black Lion, but we should also praise Wetherspoon's for their operation in Richmond.

"Many were worried about the company's reputation before they arrived at the old post office; after all, their pubs are usually aimed at younger people.

"However, The Ralph Fitz Randal has a broad appeal; in fact, the Civic Society even holds some of its meetings there," he said.

Also singled out for praise in Mr Joicey's report are the restoration and relaunch of the Georgian Theatre Royal, Richmond School's successful application for special status in the arts and the Richmond Town Centre Forum's efforts to ensure the town makes the most of national initiatives and regional initiatives.