IN A packed council chamber, members of the public by turns hissed, booed, and applauded proceedings at a meeting of Hambleton District Council planning control committee.

Councillors and planning officers were left in no doubt of the strength of opposition to a previously-approved plan to build 14 houses in Blakey Lane, Sowerby.

After a lengthy debate, the campaign to oppose John Potter's plan to develop land at The Pines, won its corner when the decision was overturned.

Last month the committee approved the plan, subject to conditions, on a site presently occupied by a detached bungalow set in large gardens. Development would also have meant the demolition of an old barn.

The plan came before councillors again on Thursday of last week so they could consider extra parking provisions, the construction of a footway, and an offer of land for a public open space.

Objectors claimed the application represented over-development of the narrow country lane, which is in a conservation area. They also said the road would be made dangerous, and that some residents would lose privacy from some of the proposed two-and-a-half storey dwellings.

Both ward representatives, Couns Mark Robson and David Murkett spoke strongly against the plan, as did Coun Peter Bardon on behalf of Sowerby Parish Council.

Opposition to the plan was led by Coun Don Cartridge, who said that not only people living nearby had registered their objections, but others from all over the village.

"We ask you to judge this plan fairly and not impose this development on the village. I'm sure you can feel the anger of the people. This developer is being too greedy. We would have accepted a smaller development," he said.

Before taking the vote, Coun Ellis said it would be beneficial if residents, planners, and developers got together to discuss where to go next if the vote went against the plan.

"It is accepted generally that some development is suitable on this site," he added.'

Although planning officers recommended approval of the plan with the new conditions, after a named vote called for by Coun Robson, the plan was refused by 15-3.

After the meeting Coun Cartridge said: "We are very pleased with the result. We have led a good campaign and virtually all the village thought this development was not right. I hope the developer now consults local residents, the parish council and everyone involved if a different plan is to be submitted.'

Mr Potter, who runs Bridge Garage in Thirsk, said afterwards it was obvious from the meeting that a different plan would be acceptable.

"It is difficult to please everyone," he said. "Planners liked the design, but locals didn't. We shall have to try and achieve a happy medium after consultation and arrive at a plan that makes everyone happy.