PLANS to build 12 flats on land next to Graceland Nursing Home, in Guisborough, have been turned down by councillors.

Objectors won the day when, following a site visit to the land off Enfield Chase last Friday, Redcar and Cleveland Borough Council's planning committee refused the application by six votes to one.

The proposal, submitted by Graceland owner Barry Parvin, had been recommended for approval by the council's development control manager, Doreen Mealing.

She told the meeting: "The site is within development limits and, in planning terms, the principle of development on this site would be difficult to argue against."

But having heard the arguments put forward by members of Belmont Residents' Association and ward councillor Alma Thrower at an earlier meeting, committee members agreed that the flats would be out of character with the area and too close to other homes in Belmangate and Whaddon Close.

Coun Brian Briggs, who proposed refusal of the application, said he felt the design was totally out of keeping with the area.

He said: "I'm concerned about the height and how close the two blocks are to other existing properties.

"I would be willing to look at another scheme, but as it is I am not willing to support the recommendation for approval."

This was echoed by the planning committee chairman, Coun Peter Spencer, who said: "I feel it is an over-development of that site ."

Coun Mary Ovens agreed and said she believed the committee had to make a stand on the issues raised.

Graham Peacock, secretary of Belmont Residents' Association, said after the meeting: "We are delighted that the vast majority of the planning committee agreed with our major objections, despite the fact that the planning officers had recommended approval.

"This lends weight to our belief that the preservation of the character of the surrounding settlement and the maintenance of the amenities enjoyed by the existing residents, should take precedence over exploitation of the site for maximum financial gain.

"May we take this opportunity to thank all those, both within and outside the residents' association, who supported our efforts in reaching this milestone."

Mr Peacock added: "Should the developers decide to lodge an appeal against the decision of the planning committee, this will be strenuously opposed by the Belmont Residents' Association.